Friday, November 8, 2013

Hating to Love Our Monsters

"A construct and a projection, the monster exists only to be read: the monstrum is etymologically ‘that which reveals,’ ‘that which warns’…”
            -Jeffrey Jerome Cohen, Monster Culture (Seven Theses)

Understanding that monsters are meant to reveal something inherently human whilst inhabiting an inhuman form makes Ridley Scott’s Alien (1979) a particularly disturbing film.  Monsters are no exception to the IA Richard’s manifesto: the alien demands to be utilized as a machine to think and demands to be extended beyond the screen.  Consider Thesis VI of monster theory:

            “Thesis VI: Fear of the Monster is Really a Kind of Desire:
The monster is continually linked to forbidden practices, in order to normalize and to enforce.  The monster also attracts.  The same creatures who terrify and interdict can evoke potent escapist fantasies; the linking of monstrosity with the forbidden makes the monster all the more appealing as a temporary egress from constraint…we distrust and loathe the monster at the same time we envy its freedom, and perhaps its sublime despair.”

This reading is simultaneously terrifying and satisfying considering the overtones of eroticism.  Reading the film in the context of the social-cultural atmosphere of its release, there is something to be said about the time’s fear of sexuality and STDs.  Perhaps more so than that, Alien reflects our desires as our culture to push the frontiers of science.  Consider the “dying” words of the mission’s android and science officer Ash, who represents the ideologies of an entire corporation from afar.  In describing the alien aboard the ship, he admires the alien while the others are utterly horrified, professing eerily:

“You don’t understand what you’re dealing with, do you?  Perfect organism.  Its structural perfection is matched only by its hostility…I admire its purity.  A survivor, unclouded by conscience, remorse, or delusions of morality.”

Ash, through the directives of Mother, wishes to aspire to the unrestricted scientific exploration that the alien embodies.  The implantation of Special Order 937 by Ash via Mother’s orders states that the number one priority is containing the alien, and that everything else is secondary.  In particular, it explicitly expresses that the “crew is expendable.”  This idea horrifies the human passengers of the Nostromo, but it encapsulates a mindset that perhaps could have saved their lives.  Rippley in particular is clouded by these delusions of morality: immediately after Ash shares his sentiments, she strays from her primary objective of preparing to blow up the ship and attempts to save Jones, the cat.

Similarly, modern science is encumbered by ethical standards.  Both human and animal participants are handled with delicacy in experiments, and often must sign lengthy legal contracts in order to take part (interesting how the crew is forced into exploring the transmission due to a contractual obligation).  These ethical standards, however, don’t translate to alien life.  Ridley Scott constructs an alien that is an erotic parasite that aligns with a science fiction trope: when alien life comes in contact with human life, they themselves dissect and probe human beings to learn of their “alien” nature as human begins would dissect and probe them in the name of science.  In Alien, it was the humans that were first strangers on an alien ship, and it is the ship’s prime directive to contain the alien in order to further the human race through science.  The alien invades the human body as a medium for asexual reproduction to further its own race. 

Alien blending into the Narcissus
The idea of the alien blending with the crux of scientific exploration can be readily understood through the alien’s ability to maneuver throughout the ship by blending in with the Nostromo’s environment.  In all of its intermediate and mature forms, the organism hides in vents, nooks, and crannies throughout the Nostromo and even hides aboard the escape shuttle, the Narcissus.  The organism’s ability to camouflage with the ship not only strengthens his representation of the aspirations of Mother and Ash, but underline the key difference between the humans and the alien: humans change their environment to suit their needs, while the alien adapts to the environment to suit its needs.

Another strong indication of the desire of science to detach from delusions of morality is Rippley’s escape.  She destroys the Nostromo, which is Italian meaning “shipmate,” and escapes aboard the Narcissus, which alludes to the Greek mythological character and the origins of narcissism: the pursuit of gratification via vanity.






No comments:

Post a Comment